Buylist Mode

CategoryOneGames

You're currently browsing our buylist ← Return to Store

Sell Your Cards & Miniatures to CategoryOneGames

We’re always looking to buy cards, miniatures, gaming magazines—even for games not currently listed on our site.
Have something to sell? Contact us at Scott@CategoryOneGames.com.

To begin, click on the appropriate set links in the left sidebar and start adding items to your buy list.


Store Credit Bonus

Get 20% more when choosing store credit over cash!


Payment Options

We offer payment via:

  • PayPal (Friends and Family preferred to avoid fees; if unavailable, we do not cover fees charged to business accounts)

  • Venmo


Condition Guidelines & Grading

  • Near Mint/Mint cards receive 100% of the listed buy price.

  • Lower condition cards (Lightly Played, Moderately Played, etc.) may receive less, based on grade and our current inventory needs.

  • If your cards arrive in worse condition than expected and we’re currently well stocked on that card/condition, the buy price may be reduced. If the value of the buy list changes more than a total of 30%, we’ll contact you to confirm whether you'd like the affected cards returned with your next order or shipped back at your expense.

We evaluate each card using natural lighting to ensure consistent grading. 


Shipping Timeframe

  • Please ship your items within 10 days of completing your sell order.

  • International orders are allowed more time, but we will send a 10-day reminder.

  • If we do not receive your cards within 60 days, the order will be canceled.


Packing Tips

  • Cards over $1: Please sleeve to protect during transit.

  • Cards under $1: Please avoid sleeving—just pack securely.

  • If you request any items to be returned, we can deduct shipping from your payout or accept PayPal to cover postage.

Please pack your cards in the order shown on your invoice. Incorrectly sorted orders may incur a sorting fee.


Where to Ship

  • USPS: Use our PO Box (listed in your confirmation email).

  • UPS / FedEx / DHL: Please contact us for the appropriate physical address.
    Do not send UPS/FedEx to the PO Box.


Shipping Reimbursement

We help offset your shipping costs based on the total value of your buy list/s shipped together:

  • Orders over $200 – Up to $20 shipping covered

  • Orders between $100–199 – Up to $10 covered

  • Orders between $40–99 – Up to $6 covered

  • Orders under $40 – Partial reimbursement based on value and demand (typically $1–2 max)

If you have multiple open buy lists, please combine them into one shipment. If sent separately, we will only reimburse one package’s shipping cost.


Important Notes

  • Items must come from a non-smoking environment. Smoky or odor-damaged items may be returned at your expense.

  • Make sure all cards are the correct set and version (foil, alt foil, etc.). Incorrect items will be added as bulk or returned. 

  • Miniatures & Star Wars Destiny must be bagged or boxed by set. Include any necessary cards or dice for each figure.


How to Submit Your Buy List

  1. Visit our online buy list and click the "Sell to Us" tab.

  2. Add the quantity of each item you'd like to sell—up to the listed amount we're currently buying.

  3. Once finished, check out and complete the required information.

  4. Include your order number and name so we know which order it is. You do not need to print the invoices.


Final Offer Disclaimer

Buy list submissions are not binding offers. We reserve the right to:

  • Adjust prices based on market changes or data entry errors.

  • Return cards in the case of oversupply, incorrect listings, or condition issues.

This policy exists only to protect against rare exceptions. 


Bulk Card Rates (Any Game)

 

  • Bulk Rares / Premiums / Foils – $1.00 per 100 cards

  • Bulk Mythics / Ultra Rares / Legendaries – $1.00 per 10 cards

  • Bulk Commons / Uncommons – $1.00 per 1,000 cards